ap
abinash phulkonwar2025-01-23
International Relation
Core theme:
- National interest define in terms of power is the basis of international relations and global politics;
- Interest and power are signpost of international relations and global politics;
- Statism: states are main actor;
- Anarchic: no higher authority;
- No morality and ethics, states are not guided by national moral principles, and not bound to any universal moral principle while protecting their national interests;
- Politics is autonomous of universal moral principle, has it's own rule of morality;
- Each state can do anything to protect their national interests depending on their relative power and capabilities;
Features:
- 3 "S": statism, survival, self-help;
- Variation in relative power among states;
- Balance of Power;
- States are rational actor, pursue their own self interests;
- Interest guided states action rather than morality;
- State pursue "security maximization" or "power maximization";
- Security Dilemma( coined by John Herz) : lack of trust- each state increasing its capabilities/power- end result heightened tension, no increase in security;
Classical Realism
- Hans Morgenthau is father of Classical Realism;
- Gave 6 principles of Realism in his book "Politics among nation" - 1948;
- Based on human nature: competitive and egoistic human nature as base of realist approach;
- Behaviors of States matches human behavior;
- Interest and power are signposts of politics;
- Politics has its own standard of morality;
- National interest, and Not national morality, decides foreign policy;
- Other thinkers: Thucydides, Thomas Hobbes, E.H. Carr, Arnold Wolfers
Neo Realism
- Propounded by Kenneth Waltz in his book "Theory of International Politics" - 1979 ;
- Instead of human nature its bases its theory on Anarchic Structure of International state system and great variation in relative powers and capabilities of states;
- Also called structural realism;
- States aim security, power is means to attain security. Hence, States are security maximiser
Offensive and Defensive Neo Realism:
Offensive | Defensive |
State are power maximiser | States are security maximiser |
States try to achieve security through domination and hegemony | Power is only means to achieve security goal |
John Mearsheimer-chief proponent | States maintain moderate and reserved policies to attain security |
| Structural modifiers- security dilemma, geography, elite beliefs and perceptions |
| Kenneth Waltz, Robert Jervis, John Herz, Stephen Walt, Jack Snyder |
Thinkers
Thucydides:
Father of Realism; His ’Melian dialogue’(on Peloponnesian War- between Athens & Sparta) is regarded as a classic realist account.
Machiavelli:
His ‘Prince’ a classic in Realism.
Thomas Hobbes:
His ‘Leviathan’ is realist in approach.
Hans Morgenthau:
- Father of IR;
- Father of classical realism;
- Interest & Power Flag post/placard of Politics;
- Interest defined in terms of power- bases of IR;
- Politics separate from morality;
Books:
- Politics Among Nations - 1948 - gave 6 principles of Classical Realism
Principles:
- Objective laws governed politics, which are rooted in human nature;
- Interest defined in terms of power;
- Interest is objective, but not fixed; No fixed meaning of national interest and power;
- Universal moral principles must be subordinated to political ones, should not be applied in the action of states;
- Difference between universal moral laws and moral aspiration of particular state. The relationship between morality and politics is complex and ambiguous;
- Autonomy of the political sphere;
E. H. Carr:
Books:
- The Twenty Years' Crisis - 1939;
Kenneth Waltz:
- Father of Neo-Realism;
Books:
- Man, the State, and War - 1959;
- Theory of International Politics - 1979 - this book gave birth to Neo-realism;
John Mearsheimer:
- Offensive Neo-realism;
- Great power competition;
- Stopping power of water;
Books:
- The Tragedy of Great Power - 2001;
Assumption:
- Anarchy: No higher or central authority above states;
- Offensive Military Capability: All states has, different in relative power;
- Uncertainty: States can never be certain of the intentions of other states;
- Survival: The primary goal of states is survival; outweighing other considerations like economic prosperity or ideological goals;
- Rationality: States are rational actors, act strategically to maximize their chances of survival;
Robert Kaplan:
- Pioneer in system approach in IR;
Books:
- ‘The Coming Anarchy (paper articles);
- Asia's Cauldron;
Robert Jervis:
- Perception and Misperception in International Politics;
Reinhold Niebuhr:
Books:
- Christian realism;
- Moral Man and Immoral Society - 1932;
- Nature and destiny of Man- 1939;